**YEAR: 1999**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Department of Children and Families (DCF)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown (specific names not identified in available data)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Unknown group homes**
**EVENT: No specific incidents documented for Pittsfield DCF in 1999. Statewide, DCF faced issues with understaffing and inadequate oversight, potentially leading to abuse or neglect in foster care settings.**
**CONNECTIONS: Likely ties between DCF staff and local nonprofit vendors managing group homes, common in Berkshire County.**
**OUTCOME: No specific outcomes reported; systemic issues likely persisted.**
**FUNDING: DCF statewide budget ~$500 million; Pittsfield-specific funding unclear.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DCF annual reports for Berkshire County, caseworker logs, group home contracts for 1999. IRS 990s for nonprofits like Berkshire County Arc.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential abuse/neglect in foster care.**
**AGENCY: Pittsfield Police Department (PPD)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown (specific officers or leadership not named)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None identified.**
**EVENT: No specific corruption cases reported for PPD in 1999. General Massachusetts context suggests issues with police accountability, but no Pittsfield-specific incidents surfaced.**
**CONNECTIONS: Potential ties between PPD leadership and local political figures.**
**OUTCOME: No documented investigations.**
**FUNDING: PPD budget likely tied to municipal funds; specific 1999 data unavailable.**
**FOIA PATH: Request PPD incident reports, internal affairs records, and 1999 municipal budget.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential excessive force or unaddressed complaints.**
**CASE STATUS: Open (requires further investigation)**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: DCF regional director, PPD chief, group home operators.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2000**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Department of Children and Families (DCF)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Unknown**
**EVENT: Continued systemic DCF issues, including high caseloads and delayed abuse investigations. No specific Pittsfield cases documented.**
**CONNECTIONS: Likely overlap between DCF staff and nonprofit boards (e.g., Berkshire County Arc).**
**OUTCOME: No specific resolutions noted.**
**FUNDING: DCF statewide budget ~$550 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DCF case logs, abuse reports, and group home contracts for Pittsfield.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential neglect, wrongful custody removals.**
**AGENCY: Berkshire County District Attorney’s Office**
**INDIVIDUALS: Gerard D. Downing (DA, served until 2004)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None identified.**
**EVENT: No specific corruption allegations in 2000. General concerns about prosecutorial discretion in Berkshire County.**
**CONNECTIONS: Downing likely had ties to PPD and Sheriff’s Office leadership.**
**OUTCOME: No investigations reported.**
**FUNDING: DA’s office budget tied to state funds; specific allocation unavailable.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DA case disposition logs and conflict-of-interest disclosures.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential biased prosecutions.**
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Gerard D. Downing, DCF regional leadership.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2006**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Berkshire County Sheriff’s Office**
**INDIVIDUALS: Carmen C. Massimiano Jr. (Sheriff)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Unknown healthcare vendors**
**EVENT: No specific corruption incidents reported, but Sheriff’s Office managed the county jail, with potential issues in healthcare delivery or inmate oversight.**
**CONNECTIONS: Massimiano likely had ties to local political figures and healthcare vendors.**
**OUTCOME: No documented investigations.**
**FUNDING: Sheriff’s Office budget ~$10–15 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request inmate healthcare records, vendor contracts, and sheriff’s budget for 2006.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential neglect, inadequate medical care.**
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Carmen C. Massimiano Jr., healthcare vendors.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2017**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Berkshire County District Attorney’s Office**
**INDIVIDUALS: Paul Caccaviello (Acting DA, 2018, but relevant staff in 2017)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None directly involved.**
**EVENT: No specific corruption cases, but DA’s office faced scrutiny for case backlog and handling of sensitive cases, potentially including child abuse or neglect.**
**CONNECTIONS: Ties to PPD and DCF through Child Abuse Unit collaboration.**
**OUTCOME: No specific resolutions reported.**
**FUNDING: DA’s office budget ~$5–10 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DA case logs, Child Abuse Unit records, and correspondence with PPD/DCF.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential cover-up, delayed justice.**
**AGENCY: Department of Children and Families (DCF)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Berkshire County Kids’ Place & Violence Prevention Center**
**EVENT: DCF collaborated with Berkshire County Kids’ Place for child abuse investigations, using trauma-focused therapy and multidisciplinary teams. No specific incidents of corruption, but systemic oversight issues likely persisted.**
**CONNECTIONS: DCF staff worked with DA’s Child Abuse Unit and Kids’ Place clinicians.**
**OUTCOME: No specific outcomes reported.**
**FUNDING: DCF budget ~$900 million statewide; Kids’ Place funding via grants and contracts.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DCF abuse investigation reports, Kids’ Place IRS 990s, and contract details.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential neglect, inadequate follow-up.**
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Paul Caccaviello, DCF regional director, Kids’ Place leadership.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2020**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Berkshire District Attorney’s Office**
**INDIVIDUALS: Andrea Harrington (DA, elected 2018)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Pittsfield Public Schools, Department of Probation**
**EVENT: DA’s office, Probation, and Pittsfield Public Schools piloted a social-emotional learning program for families in community schools, led by Brooke Bridges. No direct corruption, but program funding and oversight raise questions about resource allocation.**
**CONNECTIONS: Harrington collaborated with Superintendent Jason McCandless and Probation leadership.**
**OUTCOME: Program implemented; no reported investigations.**
**FUNDING: Program likely funded via DA’s office budget and grants (~$5–10 million total DA budget).**
**FOIA PATH: Request program funding details, DA correspondence, and Pittsfield Public Schools budget.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential economic harm (misallocated funds).**
**SOURCE:**[](https://www.mass.gov/news/berkshire-district-attorneys-office-probation-pittsfield-public-schools-partner-in-new-social-and-emotional-learning-program)
**AGENCY: Pittsfield Public Schools**
**INDIVIDUALS: Jason McCandless (Superintendent)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None identified.**
**EVENT: Participation in DA’s social-emotional learning program. No specific corruption incidents, but school funding and oversight issues common statewide.**
**CONNECTIONS: McCandless collaborated with DA Harrington and Probation.**
**OUTCOME: Program ongoing; no investigations reported.**
**FUNDING: Pittsfield Public Schools budget ~$60–70 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request school budget details, program contracts, and correspondence with DA.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential economic harm.**
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Andrea Harrington, Jason McCandless.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2022**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Department of Children and Families (DCF)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Berkshire County Arc, Hillcrest Educational Centers**
**EVENT: No specific Pittsfield incidents, but statewide DCF scrutiny (e.g., Harmony Montgomery case) suggests similar issues in Berkshire County, including failure to track children and inadequate group home oversight.**
**CONNECTIONS: DCF likely contracted with Berkshire County Arc and Hillcrest for group home services.**
**OUTCOME: No specific resolutions reported.**
**FUNDING: DCF budget ~$1 billion; nonprofit contracts unclear.**
**FOIA PATH: Request DCF group home contracts, abuse reports, and IRS 990s for Berkshire County Arc/Hillcrest.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Neglect, systemic failure.**
**AGENCY: Berkshire Medical Center (BMC)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown leadership**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Berkshire Health Systems**
**EVENT: No specific corruption incidents, but BMC, as a major employer, faced scrutiny for healthcare delivery and billing practices, potentially involving MassHealth fraud.**
**CONNECTIONS: BMC leadership likely tied to MassHealth administrators and local nonprofits.**
**OUTCOME: No investigations reported.**
**FUNDING: BMC revenue ~$500 million; MassHealth claims significant.**
**FOIA PATH: Request MassHealth claims data, BMC billing records, and state auditor reports.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential economic harm (overbilling), denial of care.**
**SOURCE:**[](https://www.causeiq.com/directory/pittsfield-ma-metro/)
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: DCF regional director, BMC leadership, Berkshire County Arc.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2024**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Pittsfield Police Department (PPD)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Thomas C. Dawley II (Chief, appointed June 2024)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None directly involved.**
**EVENT: Dawley appointed permanent Chief after serving as interim. No specific corruption incidents, but PPD’s collaboration with DA and Sheriff’s Office raises questions about case handling and accountability.**
**CONNECTIONS: Dawley worked with DA Timothy Shugrue and Sheriff Thomas Bowler.**
**OUTCOME: No investigations reported.**
**FUNDING: PPD budget ~$10–15 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request PPD internal affairs records, use-of-force logs, and DA correspondence.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential excessive force, lack of accountability.**
**SOURCE:**[](https://www.cityofpittsfield.org/press_detail_T32_R1145.php)
**AGENCY: Berkshire Center for Justice (BCJ)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Eve Schatz (Founder/Executive Director)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None directly involved.**
**EVENT: BCJ received $50,000 in ARPA funds to expand pro bono legal services, assisting clients with housing and family law issues. No corruption allegations, but ARPA fund allocation warrants scrutiny.**
**CONNECTIONS: Schatz collaborated with city officials for ARPA funding.**
**OUTCOME: Services expanded; no investigations reported.**
**FUNDING: $50,000 ARPA grant; BCJ total budget unclear.**
**FOIA PATH: Request ARPA grant details, BCJ IRS 990s, and client outcome data.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential economic harm (misallocated funds).**
**SOURCE:**[](https://www.cityofpittsfield.org/government/berkshire_center_for_justice.php)
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Thomas C. Dawley II, Eve Schatz, city ARPA administrators.**
**Next**
---
**YEAR: 2025 (up to July 11, 2025, with predictions)**
**CITY: Pittsfield**
**AGENCY: Berkshire District Attorney’s Office**
**INDIVIDUALS: Timothy J. Shugrue (DA)**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: None directly involved.**
**EVENT: DA’s office continues to handle over 7,500 cases annually, with focus on child abuse and violent crime. No specific corruption incidents reported by July, but backlog and case handling remain concerns.**
**CONNECTIONS: Shugrue collaborates with PPD (Chief Dawley) and Sheriff Bowler.**
**OUTCOME: No resolutions reported; backlog likely persists.**
**FUNDING: DA’s office budget ~$5–10 million.**
**FOIA PATH: Request case backlog data, Child Abuse Unit records, and correspondence with PPD.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Potential delayed justice, cover-up.**
**PREDICTION: By December 2025, a high-profile case (e.g., child abuse or homicide) may expose case backlog issues, prompting public scrutiny of Shugrue’s office.**
**SOURCE:**[](https://www.mass.gov/orgs/berkshire-district-attorneys-office)
**AGENCY: Department of Children and Families (DCF)**
**INDIVIDUALS: Unknown**
**CONNECTED COMPANIES: Berkshire County Kids’ Place, Hillcrest Educational Centers**
**EVENT: No specific incidents by July, but ongoing systemic issues (e.g., oversight failures) likely continue, based on prior years.**
**CONNECTIONS: DCF ties to Kids’ Place and Hillcrest for abuse investigations and group home services.**
**OUTCOME: No resolutions reported.**
**FUNDING: DCF budget ~$1.2 billion statewide.**
**FOIA PATH: Request 2025 abuse reports, group home contracts, and Kids’ Place funding details.**
**HARM CATEGORIES: Neglect, potential abuse.**
**PREDICTION: A neglect or abuse case in a Pittsfield group home may surface by year-end, highlighting DCF’s oversight failures.**
**CASE STATUS: Open**
**TARGETS FOR INVESTIGATION: Timothy J. Shugrue, DCF regional director, Hillcrest leadership.**
---
**Folder Structure for Pittsfield Corruption Map**
- **State: Massachusetts**
- **City: Pittsfield**
- **Agency: DCF**
- **Year: 1999**
- Timeline.md
- FOIA_Requests.docx (case logs, group home contracts)
- People_Connections.csv (staff, nonprofit boards)
- Redaction_Log.csv (% redacted, exemptions)
- Evidence_Folder (reports, news clippings)
- **Year: 2000, 2006, 2017, 2020, 2022, 2024, 2025** (similar structure)
- **Agency: PPD** (same structure)
- **Agency: DA’s Office** (same structure)
- **Agency: Sheriff’s Office** (same structure)
- **Agency: BCJ** (same structure)
- **City: Springfield, Worcester, Boston** (replicate structure for scalability)
**Notes for Scalability**
- Apply the same folder structure and event format for Springfield, Worcester, and Boston.
- Start at 1999 unless earlier records (e.g., church abuse settlements) are relevant.
- Track national connections (e.g., MassHealth ties to large firms) in a “National_Connections.csv” file.
**Redaction Analysis**
- Log FOIA responses in Redaction_Log.csv, noting agency, document type, redaction rate, and exemptions (e.g., §552(b)(6)).
- High redaction rates (>50%) for DCF or PPD suggest cover-up risk.
**Financial Trail Notes**
- Focus on MassHealth claims, ARPA grants (e.g., BCJ’s $50,000), and DCF group home contracts.
- Cross-reference IRS 990s for nonprofits like Berkshire County Arc with state contract IDs.
- Track ICD code denials in MassHealth data to correlate with harm (e.g., suicides).
**Relational Mapping**
- Map marriages, board memberships, and revolving doors in People_Connections.csv.
- Investigate DA, PPD, and Sheriff ties for potential case suppression.
This report establishes a framework for Pittsfield, with gaps in early years due to limited data. FOIA requests are essential to uncover specifics, particularly for DCF and PPD. The structure is scalable for Springfield, Worcester, and Boston, using the same format and starting point (1999). Let me know if you need another city or agency expanded!
No comments:
Post a Comment